I bought the bronze to match the hardware and shower curtain rod in my daughters bathroom and they are much lighter than pictured and expected. I think there’s one picture in the original sale photos that more accurately show the color. Otherwise they are very nice and so far have been exactly what I’d hope - Just beware they arn’t as “bronze” as most bronze products.I wish I had known these existed long ago. This literally made hanging a shower curtain and liner so fast and simple I don't ever want to use another hook or ring again. They roll well on the balls the the curtain and liner stay put just fine. There is a shorter side and a longer side. I put the fabric side on the shorter side so the vinyl curtain drops down farther on the other side. That way it's not seen when you are done.One tip I can give you is to hang the hooks on the rod, put your lighter weight side on first and then then the heavier fabric/vinyl. I did it just the opposite to start with and they ended up turning too far on the rod and fell off. When I did it the other way, it worked just fine.Surprisingly good quality. One side is longer than the other- make sure you are using the long side for your clear shower curtain (I had to flip all of mine after I hung it the first time)They don’t allow you to easily move shower curtain to open and close to get in and out of shower. It’s the only drawbackThis product is an elegant and graceful option when you have one rod, and need two curtains. I use this double hook ball bearing hook as an alternative to having a single clasp ball bearing Low hanging hook. I never liked that my shower curtain liner was always visible when attached to the single hook options because two curtains would be touching on top. This double hook is far superior to my old thin cheap looking hook that left a large gap between the tension rod and the shower curtain. I also appreciate that one hook is lower so the shower curtain liner is less visible. My only complaint is that the color is more of a dark pewter /silver rather than an oil rubbed bronze.These slide so easily on our shower rod over the hook styled ones, they also have notches so none of the slider balls will come off which happened with the last set of hooks we had. Makes removing the clear shower curtains much easier. Our shower bar is a bit thicker than average and these slide really easily and don't get hung up where the bars are connected to adjust it.These hooks are a brilliant idea. I can remove one curtain at a time for washing and put them back up with a lot of ease.I have found the other types of curtain hooks to be so cumbersome. My mom absolutely hates to have to put back up the shower curtains, she gets so frustrated with the hooks.These are amazing. We are really glad we purchased these. They are of good quality and sturdy constructed.Product arrived very quick. The rollers don't work all that well but the functionality is not really affected. It would be 5 stars if rollers were better but for the price they are OK. The ones at home depot are heavier and the rollers are much better but they are also 2x the price. I would have to say properly functioning rollers isn't worth 2x the price of these ones. I would probably buy them again.Made my life so much easier! I like to have cousins one inside one decorative for the outside and this made it so much easier. Must have product if use 2 shower curtainsCan't really ask for more with the price being so good.I like that is has separate hooks for the liner and the curtain. The chrome finish matches my rod well.The glide easily. Sometimes they call off the rod but I am guessing that is more because of the way we are opening and closing the curtain, rather than a defect of the product.I have had these up for 2 months now. No rusting and they still roll nicely. They add a nice touch of detail to my bathroom. Would definitely recommend.